美语听力与发音技巧第13期 | YES or NO
摘要: 在英语中,回答“Yes/No”问题时,“Yes”必须对应肯定陈述,“No”必须对应否定陈述,这与中文习惯不同,尤其在面对否定疑问句或语调升高的陈述式问句时容易出错。
- 英语中“Yes”后必须接肯定句,如“Yes, I do.”;“No”后必须接否定句,如“No, I don’t.”
- 中文允许“Yes”后接否定内容(如“是的,我没吃”),但英语严格禁止此类结构。
- 面对否定疑问句(如“Don’t you speak English?”),正确回答仍遵循“Yes + 肯定”或“No + 否定”的规则。
- 当用升调将陈述变为疑问(如“You didn’t eat dinner?”),回答“Yes”表示“我吃了”,而非“你说得对(我没吃)”。
- 若想确认对方陈述正确,应使用“That’s correct.”而非“Yes”来避免歧义。
请点击下方条形框播放音频
Welcome to Daily Tips on Learning English. Today’s tip is on answering “Yes/No” questions correctly.
In English, “Yes” is always followed by affirmative statements. “No” is always followed by negative statements.
This means you can’t say, “Yes, I haven’t eaten dinner yet.” Or “No, I did my home work.” Chinese allows this, but English does not. There’re different kinds of “Yes/No” questions. Simple “Yes/No” questions such as “Do you speak English?” “Are you hungry?” pose no problem. But negative questions such as “Don’t you speak English?” “Aren’t you hungry?” require the same answers. “Yes, I do.” “No, I don’t.” or “Yes, I am.” “No, I’m not.” Chinese learners of English are often misled by negative questions, and answer, “Yes, I don’t speak English.” Or “Yes, I’m not hungry.” by accident. Another type of “Yes/No” questions is to use a rising intonation with a statement. For example, you ask a Chinese person, “Did you eat dinner?” and he says, “No, I didn’t.” You’re surprised, so you ask, “You didn’t eat dinner?” and he answers, “Yes.” instead of “No”. Don’t use “yes” to mean “是的”. You should say, “That’s correct.” In the example above, “Yes” means “Yes, I ate dinner.” Not “Correct, I didn’t eat dinner.
Let’s look at another example. I think that all Chinese people like to eat rice. So, when my Chinese friend tells me that he never eats rice, I was very surprised, and I ask, “You don’t like to eat rice?” and he answers, “Yes.” This is wrong. Because in English, you can not say, “Yes, I don’t like to eat rice.” He should answer, “No.” or “That’s correct.” So remember, “Yes” must be followed by affirmative statements, and “No” must be followed by negative statements.
This has been today’s daily tip on learning English. Tune in tomorrow for another tip.
常见问题
为什么不能说“Yes, I don’t like rice.”?
因为英语中“Yes”必须与肯定陈述搭配,正确说法是“No, I don’t like rice.”或“That’s correct.”
听到“You didn’t eat dinner?”该怎么回答?
如果确实没吃,应回答“No.”;如果说“Yes.”,会被理解为“我吃了晚饭”。
中文母语者常在“Yes/No”回答上犯什么错误?
常按中文思维用“Yes”表示认同对方的否定陈述,如“Yes, I’m not hungry.”,这在英语中语法错误且逻辑矛盾。
如何正确回应带有惊讶语气的陈述式问句?
应根据事实选择“Yes”(肯定事实)或“No”(否定事实),或使用“That’s correct.”明确表示认同对方说法。
参考资料
美语听力与发音技巧第13期 | YES or NO
本文内容基于该音频课程脚本整理,聚焦英语“Yes/No”问答的语法规则与常见误区。